Open Pit Protection at CHC Zagreb – Rebro: Construction-Stage Adaptations, Monitoring and Verification of Actual Structural Behaviour
In the first part of the CHC Zagreb – Rebro project overview, we presented the development of the open pit protection solutions – from geotechnical investigations and the BIM model development to numerical analyses and the final design solution.
In complex geotechnical projects, however, design does not end when construction begins. As excavation progresses, the exact locations of existing structures and utilities become clearer, requiring continuous assessment and design adjustment to reflect the actual conditions encountered on site.
From the Design Model to Actual Site Conditions
The hospital building open pit is being constructed within an active hospital complex, immediately adjacent to existing buildings, communication tunnels, utilities and traffic areas. Due to these spatial constraints, some of the designed elements had to be locally adapted during construction to the actual conditions encountered on site.
The modifications included relocating piles, capping beams and anchors to avoid clashes with utilities, sewers and tunnels. In some areas, additional protection zones were established to enable safe excavation adjacent to existing buildings and roads that had to remain operational throughout construction.
The area adjacent to the existing communication tunnel was particularly demanding. Due to limited space, some of the 800 mm diameter piles were replaced with 600 mm diameter piles, together with the introduction of an additional row of anchors. In the strutted zone, the support and bracing system for the steel struts was further developed to reduce their unsupported spans and facilitate construction.

Adaptations without Changing the Basic Design Concept
The modifications introduced during construction did not represent a change in the basic open pit protection concept, but rather a more detailed adaptation of the design to the conditions encountered as the works progressed.
Similar local adaptations were also implemented in the open parking garage area. The positions of individual piles and capping beams were adjusted to the existing and proposed sewer systems, additional piles were installed, and the installation levels and inclinations of individual anchors were modified due to underground utilities. The method of surface protection for the sloped excavations was also adapted.
Throughout this process, the BIM model remained a working platform for checking the relationship between the newly identified site conditions and the designed elements. This enabled construction-stage changes to be assessed spatially before their final design development.

Monitoring – Verification of Actual Behaviour
In addition to designer supervision, monitoring of the open pit protection structure and adjacent buildings formed an important part of the construction process. The monitoring system included several types of measurements aimed at assessing both the behaviour of the protection structure itself and the potential influence of the open pit construction on surrounding buildings.
Horizontal displacements of the bored pile walls were monitored using vertical inclinometers installed in selected piles. Clinometers were installed on adjacent buildings to monitor potential deviations from the vertical, while extensometers were additionally used in the operating theatre block area to monitor changes in the width of the existing expansion joint. In this way, the monitoring system covered both deformation of the open pit protection structure and the response of the immediately adjacent buildings.

The results of inclinometer monitoring were compared with the displacements previously obtained from numerical analyses performed in PLAXIS 2D. For the final excavation stage, corresponding to excavation to the design bottom level of the open pit, the measured displacements were generally lower than the calculated values.
Very good agreement was also recorded at individual monitoring locations. For example, at one representative section, the calculated horizontal displacement was approximately 18 mm, while the measured inclinometer displacement was approximately 17 mm. In addition to the maximum displacement values, the shape of the deformation profile with depth provides another interesting basis for comparison. At several monitoring locations, the measured deformation profile closely follows the deformation pattern predicted by the numerical model.

Monitoring of the adjacent buildings did not indicate significant deformations associated with the open pit construction. Measured changes in inclination were negligible, while changes in the width of the operating theatre block expansion joint were predominantly associated with temperature effects.
The Observational Method in Practice
This approach represents a practical application of the observational approach in geotechnical design. Numerical analysis provides a prediction of the expected structural response, monitoring shows the actual behaviour, while designer supervision enables newly identified site conditions to be incorporated into the further development of the design in a timely manner.
On the CHC Zagreb – Rebro project, the BIM model, numerical analyses, designer supervision and monitoring were therefore not separate processes. Together, they formed an integrated system through which the design solution was continuously verified and adapted to the actual conditions encountered during construction.
For complex open pits in densely built-up environments, this type of approach enables the project to remain controlled even when actual site conditions differ from the information available at the design stage.
Read more: Open pit protection at KBC Zagreb – Rebro; From Site Investigation to BIM-Based Design